Fail-Proof Homemade Mayonnaise Recipe

How to make mayonnaise in less than 10 minutes! Using whole eggs instead of just the yolk, makes this homemade mayonnaise recipe practically fail-proof and extra easy.

Watch the Video

I’ve used this mayonnaise recipe more times than I can count. If you’ve never tried homemade mayonnaise, then you are in for a treat. Homemade mayo is ultra creamy and so much more flavorful than anything you can buy at the store. Here’s why I love this recipe so much:

• Our recipe uses whole eggs instead of just the yolks so you can skip separating the eggs.
• The remaining ingredients are simple and very likely in your kitchen right now.
• The whole process takes less than 10 minutes.
• You can add extra ingredients for more flavor (like roasted garlic or herbs). I’ve shared suggestions below.

Homemade mayo lasts about two weeks in the fridge, but in all honesty, once I have a batch in my fridge, it usually goes quicker than that. I love using it to make sandwiches like egg salad or chicken salad, and I find it makes creamy salads like potato salad and macaroni salad extra special.

Mayonnaise ingredients

The ingredients to make mayo are simple — we bet you even have them in your kitchen right now. You will need the following:

• Egg — You need to use egg to make mayonnaise. We do use raw egg in the recipe. For mayonnaise made without egg, see our vegan mayonnaise recipe. Personally, I don’t have an issue adding raw egg to the recipe, but if you are concerned about eating raw eggs, buy pasteurized eggs. They are sold in the egg section of the grocery store. You can also pasteurize eggs yourself, just search for a tutorial online.
• Mustard — I know that not everyone loves the flavor of mustard, but when it comes to making homemade mayonnaise mustard is sort of a magical ingredient. Mustard adds a bit of flavor, but it also helps to keep the mayonnaise stable. Along with the egg yolk, mustard helps emulsify the mixture, reducing the risk of our mayo breaking.
• Vinegar or lemon juice — Not only does a little acid like wine vinegar, champagne vinegar, and lemon juice add incredible flavor to the mayonnaise, it also helps to stabilize the mixture.
• Neutral Flavored Oil — By neutral flavored oil, I mean use an oil that is light in flavor. Quite a bit of oil is added to make mayonnaise, so it’s important to like the flavor of the oil you use. For a clean tasting mayonnaise use something like grape seed, safflower, avocado or canola oil. Since posting the recipe, quite a few readers have asked about olive oil in mayonnaise. You can use olive oil, but it can be a little overpowering so I prefer to use a brand that’s light and fruity. I think robust or spicy olive oils would be too much. You might also consider only replacing half of the oil called for in the recipe with olive oil and use something more neutral for the rest.

Let me show you how to make mayonnaise, you’ve got this!

There are a few ways to make mayonnaise. We use our food processor with the small bowl attachment, but an immersion blender or making it completely by hand will work. (Expect tired arms and strong biceps if you do choose to do it by hand.)

Room temperature ingredients are best when making mayonnaise at home. If you’re not able to wait for the egg to come to room temperature, submerge it in lukewarm (not hot) water for a couple of minutes.

The Five Steps For Making Mayonnaise

1. Prepare your food processor. I prefer to use the small bowl attachment that came with our food processor to make mayonnaise.
2. Add an egg to the bowl of your food processor and process for about 20 seconds.
3. Add mustard, vinegar, and salt then process for another 20 seconds.
4. Slowly add the oil, in tiny drops, until about a quarter of the oil has been added. Adding the oil slowly is really important. If you were to dump it all in at once, you’d have mayonnaise soup!
5. Taste the mayonnaise and adjust with additional salt and vinegar or lemon juice.

Mayonnaise variations

I love this classic mayonnaise as-is, but love it even more when I make it my own. I almost always add a squeeze of lemon juice to brighten things up a little. I love how fresh it makes it taste. Fresh herbs, roasted garlic, chipotle, Sriracha or curry powder are all amazing options, as well. You might also enjoy our garlic aioli recipe, which is very similar to this recipe, but uses egg yolks instead of whole eggs.

How to fix broken mayonnaise

When making mayonnaise, the worst, but not unfixable, thing that can happen to you is that the mixture breaks, leaving you with a curdled mess. The recipe we’ve shared tries to prevent this a few ways: we use a whole egg, which adds a little more liquid to the mix, mustard acts as an emulsifier from the get-go and we are careful to stream our oil in slowly.

While we have never had this particular recipe for mayonnaise break on us, if it happens to you don’t fret! You really should be able to fix it. Here are two suggestions for fixing broken or thin mayonnaise:

• Add about 1 teaspoon of mustard to a bowl then use a whisk to slowly beat the broken mayonnaise, bit by bit, into the mustard until it becomes emulsified and creamy again.
• Add an egg yolk to a large bowl and slowly use a whisk to beat the broken mayo, bit by bit, into the yolk.

Do I have to use raw eggs to make mayonnaise?

Eggs are essential for making mayonnaise. Risks of using raw eggs are low, but there is a chance that the egg contains a germ called Salmonella. Personally, I am not too concerned about this, but here’s what the CDC suggests you do to reduce the risks of using eggs:

• Consider buying and using pasteurized eggs
• Keep eggs refrigerated at 40°F (4°C) or colder at all times.
• Only buy eggs from stores and suppliers that keep them refrigerated.
• Discard cracked or dirty eggs.

Do I need to use mustard?

You can make homemade mayonnaise without mustard, but remember that mustard is one of the fail-safes we have added to our recipe to encourage an emulsification.

Can I use olive oil to make mayo?

Yes, but keep in mind that quite a bit of oil is called for in the recipe so a strong or robust flavored oil will make the mayonnaise strong in flavor. When I use olive oil, I like using a light, fruity brand and only replace half of the oil with olive oil and use a neutral flavored oil for the remaining oil.

My mayonnaise won’t thicken, what am I doing wrong?

Ugh, I’m sorry! Broken mayonnaise happens to everyone and it doesn’t necessarily mean that you did something wrong or that the recipe you used was a bad one. The key thing to keep in mind when making mayo is to add that oil slowly, and by slowly, I honestly mean to add it drop by drop.

I know it seems extreme, but it’s the best way to ensure creamy mayo. Mayonnaise can be finicky so if it breaks on you or it just doesn’t thicken, there are some things you can do to fix it. Take a look above in the article where I outline a couple of fixes to broken mayo.

How long does homemade mayonnaise last?

Here’s the thing, homemade mayo will last as long as your eggs would have lasted. A good rule of thumb is that mayo will keep covered in the fridge up two weeka, but you might find that it lasts a little longer depending on the freshness of your eggs.

Delicious ways to use homemade mayonnaise

Fail-Proof Homemade Mayonnaise

Makes approximately 1 cup

Nutrition Per Serving
Serving Size
1 tablespoon
/
Calories
126
/
Protein
0 g
/
Carbohydrate
0 g
/
Dietary Fiber
0 g
/
Total Sugars
0 g
/
Total Fat
14 g
/
Saturated Fat
1 g
/
Cholesterol
12 mg

AUTHOR: 

Adam and Joanne Gallagher